Pakistani JF17 Outperforms American F-15, Fueling Saudi Deal: International Military Watch

Pakistani JF17 Outperforms American F-15, Fueling Saudi Deal: International Military Watch

ISLAMABAD: Emerging reports from the first week of January 2026 havesparked intense discussion in defence circles, as the Royal Saudi Air Forcecontemplates a major procurement of Chinese-origin JF-17 Thunder fighteraircraft from Pakistan, valued between $4 billion and $6 billion. Thispotential deal, which would mark Saudi Arabia’s first acquisition ofnon-Western fighters, has prompted analyses suggesting that the JF-17 Block3 variant demonstrates advantages in certain modern combat parameters overthe American F-15, particularly in avionics and missile technology derivedfrom fifth-generation platforms.

The speculation centres on Military Watch Magazine’s detailed assessments,which argue that the JF-17 Block 3 incorporates advanced technologiesborrowed from China’s J-20 stealth fighter, positioning it as a highlysophisticated lightweight platform. Observers note that while the RoyalSaudi Air Force maintains a formidable fleet including approximately 152F-15s, 72 Eurofighters, and 80 Tornados—with the 84 F-15SA modelsrepresenting the most capable fourth-plus-generation assets—theintroduction of JF-17 could reshape operational dynamics through costefficiency and technological parity in specific domains.

Central to these comparisons is the JF-17 Block 3’s integration ofcutting-edge systems, including an active electronically scanned arrayradar, helmet-mounted displays, infrared search and track capabilities, andfly-by-wire controls. Such features mirror advancements found infifth-generation fighters, enabling superior situational awareness andbeyond-visual-range engagements. In contrast, Saudi F-15SA aircraft, thoughheavily upgraded with American technologies, rely on older AIM-120C andAIM-9X missiles, which analysts contend are outranged and outmanoeuvred bythe JF-17’s PL-15 and PL-10 armaments.

The PL-15 missile, with its estimated 200-300 kilometre range and activeradar guidance, provides a decisive edge in long-distance air-to-aircombat, potentially allowing JF-17 pilots to engage threats beforeopponents can respond effectively. This capability stems directly fromChina’s combat aviation leadership, as the country—alongside the UnitedStates—remains at the forefront of fifth- and emerging sixth-generationfighter development. Projections indicate China’s sixth-generationplatforms may enter service three to six years ahead of Americanequivalents, underscoring the rapid evolution of technologies now embeddedin export-oriented aircraft like the JF-17.

Furthermore, the JF-17 Block 3’s design philosophy emphasises lowoperational costs, ease of maintenance, and high reliability, attributesthat contrast sharply with the high-maintenance demands of heavyweightfighters such as the F-15SA. Saudi Arabia’s current fleet faces logisticalchallenges due to dependence on Western supply chains, raising concernsover potential vulnerabilities in protracted conflicts or geopoliticalshifts. The lightweight Chinese fighter offers a complementary role,potentially forming a high-low mix where F-15s handle air superiority anddeep strikes, while JF-17s manage interception, patrol, and secondarydefence tasks.

This prospective diversification aligns with Saudi Arabia’s broaderstrategy to hedge against uncertainties in U.S. commitments, especiallyamid ongoing regional tensions. The deal’s structure—potentially offsettingportions of Pakistan’s outstanding loans—adds a financial dimension,facilitating procurement without immediate large cash outlays. Pakistan,facing economic pressures, views such exports as critical for bolsteringits defence industry and reducing reliance on external aid.

Analyses also highlight that the JF-17 Block 3, though lighter and lesscostly than the F-15, achieves comparable or superior performance in keyfourth-plus-generation metrics through newer radar designs and electronicwarfare suites. While the F-15 excels in payload, speed, and range as aheavyweight platform, the JF-17’s agility and advanced sensors could provedecisive in networked, missile-centric engagements typical of contemporaryair warfare.

Should the procurement proceed, it would represent a landmark shift for theRoyal Saudi Air Force, introducing indigenous Chinese-Pakistani technologyalongside established Western systems. This move could enhance fleetresilience, provide training pathways toward fifth-generation operations,and reflect evolving global defence procurement trends favouringdiversified suppliers.

The discussions underscore deepening Pakistan-Saudi military ties,reinforced by a recent mutual defence pact and high-level visits. Asnegotiations continue, the potential integration of JF-17 fighters raisesprofound questions about future airpower balances in the Middle East andbeyond.

Source:https://militarywatchmagazine.com/article/what-role-chinese-jf17-saudi-procurement

Tags: Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, JF-17 Thunder, Royal Saudi Air Force, F-15Eagle

ogimageimage-name